Thermapen Instant Thermometer – Worth the Money?
After years of wasting money on different brands of instant read thermometers and having less than desirable results, I recently got a Thermoworks Thermapen. For most home cooks, you are probably asking what is a Thermapen? It is an extremely accurate digital instant read thermometer. Thermoworks the company that manufactures Thermapen is renowned for their scientific equipment and has branched from thermometers for the science community to the culinary community.
For the home cook, their Thermapen is pricey at $89 compared to the instant reads you will find in all the kitchen stores regionally. Having previously owned Rosle, Taylor, All Clad and Williams Sonoma’s instant read thermometers, ranging in cost from $20 – $42, I can attest to the fact that none of these other brands even come close to the Thermpen’s accuracy and speed.
All but the All Clad thermometer have left my kitchen due to either not working consistently, registering 10 – 15 degrees off (unfortunately normally this results in overdone meat,) or requiring a full 45 seconds to register any legible temperature. I have owned many other brands, but they were so insignificant in this arena, I can’t even recall the brand names.
As much as I love All Clad, their thermometers are the only product I have ever purchased from them that I am disappointed with. I recognize that I am tweeked for all things kitchen related, but, If I had all the money that I wasted on the other brand’s instant reads, I could own several Thermapens.
In fairness, I am comparing a commercial grade thermometer to a mass produced “home kitchen” thermometer. There is a world of difference in both quality and price. The Thermapen offers splash proof which means you can use their thermometer with wet hands. The digital temp tonight read within seconds and was spot on. I could actually watch the temperature change as I slid the thermometer into the roast. I pulled the roast from the oven at 125.4 degrees and let it rest and was delighted to have achieved a perfectly rare roast upon carving. The All-clad showed its temperature at 114 taken seconds after the Thermapen.
The additional automatic shut off (I’ve killed numerous digital thermometers by them being left on in a drawer) is a nice feature as well. For some, the ability to flip between Celsius and Fahrenheit may also be a plus. This doesn’t really add any benefit in my kitchen. The Thermapen is hand-assembled and tested and uses a professional thermocouple circuit design. These thermometers are used in professional kitchens and by the safety inspectors who check temperatures in restaurants. Thermoworks is also a US company. I do happen to like that as well.
The downside, this particular model is $89. Most home cooks probably cannot justify $89 versus $20. If you’re only going to use the thermometer as a guide of when to pull and not rely on it for accuracy, then $20 will work for you. If you are a control freak in the kitchen (like me) and don’t want to waste good money on an expensive roast this holiday season (specifically if you like your meat rare or medium rare rather than well done) then perhaps it’s an investment worth making.
As I said at the beginning of this review, there really isn’t anything in the kitchen stores that compares to the Thermapen as far as professional instant read. The nearest comparable professional instant read online was over $200.
I consider the Thermapen an accurate, fast, easy to use thermometer which doesn’t require elaborate instructions or me to deduct 15 degrees and hope the roast isn’t medium well after resting. I also like that the Thermapen doesn’t tell me when the roast is done by some of the new “enforced” settings like their “medium rare” setting instead of when the roast is at 130 – 135 degrees.
As a final note, Thermoworks does offer a less expensive super fast pocket thermometer which isn’t water resistant and a waterproof pocket without an auto on/off switch for $19 each. I haven’t tried any of these, but for $19, I am thinking of giving them a try. Both of these thermometers are marketed for the average home cook and are comparable to Taylor’s non-digital instant read. Perhaps if I get around to purchasing one of these models it would be a more fair comparison that the one I’m trying to draw here.
Bottom line – A quality product which is a stretch for a lot of home chefs but definitely delivers what it promises.